Jul 7, 2021 - This Pin was discovered by Beatrizfalitz. 12:44:14 - the engine power is reduced to flight idle. Four seconds later, the aircraft begins striking the treetops. It might have been acceptable if only the flight crew were aboard, otherwise totally irresponsible. Accident, incident and crash related photos, Air to Air But the airline is ultimately at fault for allowing such a low unprepared fly over. Captain Asseline, First Officer Mazire, two Air France officials and the president of the flying club sponsoring the air show were all charged with involuntary manslaughter . The plane crashed because of a design defect; but because it was software and not metal, it was ignored. You are Captain Michel Asseline. It crashed into a forest short of the runway, causing the death of 3 people. He then tried to open the left-side forward door, which was blocked by trees. *Management often screws around. Also punished with suspended sentences were Air Frances then-director of air operations, a security official for Air France, and the president of the Habsheim air club. And we dont share your email with anyone. Apart from the tail section, the aircraft was consumed by fire. His job was to find its limitations, but one slipped past him, and Airbus and all the designers and engineers. They said the plane was not at fault. [1] A training captain since 1979, Asseline was appointed to head the company's A320 training subdivision at the end of 1987. Captain Michel Asseline "44" Second Officer Pierre Mazire "45" Captain Asseline has logged 10,463 flight hours while First Officer Maziere . This type of oversight, if you want to call it that, happens ALL the time, in programming software, as well as all other types of engineering. If you change the pilots cap for a lab coat, arent you Captain Michel Asseline, too? But upon seeing the Aerodrome, the pilot saw that the audience were gathered elsewhere, on Runway 34R. 3 people died due to smoke. The captain of this Aircraft should take responsibility for his actions instead of trying to clear his name. Air France Flight 296Q was a chartered flight of a new Airbus A320-111 operated by Air France for Air Charter International. I'm confident in my skills & my co workers often come to me with questions or for help and always no matter how busy I am I gladly help them. [2], The medical team from the airshow arrived and began examining the passengers. Spectral analysis of the engine sounds indicated that 0.6 seconds later, both engines had reached 91% (by this stage, they were starting to ingest vegetation). The evacuation from the rear door had been fast and smooth thanks to the instructions from the flight attendants at the rear of the aircraft. He was not given a map and route. [5][6], The plane's flight recorders were found still attached in the unburnt tail section. Since the plane was going slow, the computer overrode his input, and denied the maneuver. Not easy, but not impossible. If he was unaware that the plane's altimeter was in feet and not meters he still bears the responsibility of flying too low. The accident aircraft, an Airbus A320-111, registration F-GFKC, serial number 9, first flew on 6 January 1988 and was delivered to Air France on 23 June, three days prior to its destruction. The first crash that comes to mind is the one where that CRJ2 crashed because it took off on the wrong runway and the only survivor was one of the pilots. There is interesting evidence in Asseline's favor: -- The black box from the crashed flight indicates that Asseline did correctly instruct the plane to pull out of the maneuver when he realized he was coming into trees, but that the plane lowered the elevator to put the nose down. Finally, the aircraft would return to Paris. Guilty. He wanted to pop up 70 feet to get over the trees. Captain Michel Asseline served a year in prison. Both pilots Captain Asseline and First Officer Mazire survived. I have a hard time believing that the pilot was literally four seconds from the trees when he applied power. Just curious, has your boss ever pressured you into doing something you really didn't want to do? Michel Asseline was the pilot in command of F-GFKC, Pierre Mazire was his first officer, when the aircraft overflew the airfield at 2 pm in wonderful sunny weather. The pilot and copilot were charged and convicted of three counts of involuntary manslaughter in the French criminal courts. It threatened to ruin the reputation of the A320, potentially losing many millions of dollars in sales. Captain Michel Asseline, 44, had been an airline pilot with Air France for almost 20 years and had the following endorsements: Caravelle, Boeing 707, 727, and 737, and Airbus A300 and A310.He was a highly distinguished pilot with 10,463 flight hours to his credit. Today, the captain, Michel Asseline has lost his French pilot license for 8 years. Respond with some you can think of! Claiming he couldnt hear or read the radio altimeter is ridiculous. Captain Asseline was flying to Mont Blanc, period. -- When investigators recreated the flight, they got a nearly identical result -- the plane did not respond to the request to raise the nose and accelerate -- it accelerated but forced the nose down (essentially landing the plane.) He has admitted these mistakes and paid for them. He wanted to pop up 70 feet to get over the trees. The Airbus A320 couldnt handle it. Local emergency services were informed by radio communication. If he maintained 100ft, the aicraft would've missed the 40ft trees! Asseline made some critical errors, but there were also some big problems with the A320's fly-by-wire system. I just watched "Mayday" which dealt with the crash of Flight 296. I have no doubt the pilot was to blame, and the conspiracy theorists (tampering with a black box?) The plan was to overfly Runway Ought-2; the aircraft was configured for a low-altitude overflight. Decisions can only be made after a proper investigation. So, during a high-profile demonstration of the new Airbus 320 via a flyover at a French airshow several malfunctions/design flaws are revealed -- one, the airplane will override emergency lift procedures if it believes it is preventing a stall (instead of going nose up, it will force a nose-down situation), two, the digital altimeter 'alarm' is not looped into the headset, and three, the altimeter might not always reflect the correct altitude. The A320 had been recently introduced, and Flight 296 was the first passenger flight of the A320. In the US it's called ASAP. Any doctor who tries to practice in medicine today, except for my colleagues in Direct Primary Care, live in the world of Captain Michel Asseline every day. The pilot was told, word-of-mouth, to do so. In 1997, all five were found guilty. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. He continued flying and after two years he became a captain again Everyone airminded in France knows that Michel Asseline, who was an Air France chief pilot instructor at the beginning of the Airbus A-320 era and PIC in the A-320 that crashed at Mulhouse-Habsheim airfield in June 1988, resumed his career some years after the accident as a Boeing-737 pilot in Australia. I am Captain Michel Asseline. When the crew suddenly asked the plane for more power and lift, it may have simply ignored them. TOGA power is applied. There's every reason to suspect Airbus is correct, that many crashes have been prevented. IMDbPro. The purser, a passenger, and a flight attendant (a guest from another airline) managed to push the door fully open. Five individuals, including the captain and first officer, were later found guilty of involuntary manslaughter. 12:45:06 - the aircraft descends through 200 feet (61m) at an airspeed of 155 knots. A website, http://www.crashdehabsheim.net/ has been set up to analyze the scandal. The evidence is clear - the plane was at alphamax (high angle of attack), at very low airspeed, and with engine set to idle. [2], Traditionally, pilots respect the inherent dangers of flying at low speeds at low altitude, and normally, a pilot would not attempt to fly an aircraft so close to stalling with the engines at flight idle (minimum thrust setting in flight). Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. F-GFKC, the Airbus A320 involved in the accident, Aviation accidents and incidents in France, Includes overseas departments and overseas territories, Bureau of Enquiry and Analysis for Civil Aviation Safety, List of accidents and incidents involving commercial aircraft, "Commission d'Enqute sur l'accident survenu le 26 de juin de 1988 Mulhouse-Habsheim (68) l'Airbus A 320, immatricul F-GFKC Rapport Final", "ASN Aircraft accident Airbus A320-111 F-GFKC Mulhouse-Habsheim Airport", "Air France Airbus A320-111 (F-GFKC) flight AF296Q", "Air France flight AF296Q English official report", "Pilot who crashed jet in air show gets jail time", "The Airbus A320 crash at Habsheim, France 26 June 1988", Commission of Inquiry into the accident on 26 June 1988 in MulhouseHabsheim, March 1952 Air France SNCASE Languedoc crash, 2021 Touques Airbus AS350B helicopter crash, Compagnie Internationale de Navigation Arienne, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Air_France_Flight_296Q&oldid=1133625633, Accidents and incidents involving the Airbus A320, Airliner accidents and incidents caused by pilot error, Aviation accidents and incidents at air shows, Aviation accident investigations with disputed causes, Airliner accidents and incidents involving controlled flight into terrain, Conspiracy theories involving aviation incidents, Articles with French-language sources (fr), Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0. Related news. Quote: "and there were trees that shouldn't have been in the area. Therefore, Captain Asseline has to also take some responsibility for those that died and those that were maimed for life. If I did know their names I certainly would not tell you. And in the end its all a metter of money and intrest. Airliners.net is the leading community for discovering and sharing high-quality aviation photography. 3 passengers died in the accident and about 50 were injured. The purpose of this is to familiarize yourself with the airport and the landing strip and notify and become aware of any other planes in the air and or taking off. Privacy Policy. He was supposed to conduct a low-level pass over the runway at . as a pilot my self the rules are for made for a reason they are not to be broken by a pilot for his own or anyone's purpose. Everyone airminded in France knows that Michel Asseline, who was an Air France chief pilot instructor at the beginning of the Airbus A-320 era and PIC in the A-320 that crashed at Mulhouse-Habsheim airfield in June 1988, resumed his career some years after the accident as a Boeing-737 pilot in Australia. The captain would make a low-level fly-pass over Runway 02, climb up and turn back, and repeat the fly-pass over the same runway in the reciprocal direction (Runway 20). They cannot possibly convict him of manslaughter when the black boxes were switched and there are 8 seconds missing from the recording. It was piloted by a premier captain of Air France, Captain Michel Asseline, with over10,000 air hours, and led the training division of Air France for qualifying pilots on the Airbus 320. If we try to eliminate error altogether, we're kidding ourselves. Michel Asseline. Facts: 1) new plane (model/style) = bugs still to be discovered & pilots not familiar w how plane functions (new technology / automation) 2) pilot was not familiar w air field not shown air field and only given a map of it (inaccurate map showing no terrain) right before the flight 3) air France never should have had people on the flight except crew knowing all these factors. [2] The flyover had been approved by Air France's Air Operations Directorate and Flight Safety Department, and air traffic control and Basel tower had been informed. There is a CA that I knew that turned his T-Tail aircraft into the wing of another aircraft and he remained with the same company but ended up as a ground instructor for situational awareness classes. Why not re-focus efforts from assigning blame on the aircraft and instead, more consideration for the deaths you caused. He had to spot the airfield from the air and prepare to do the overflight. However, while the pilots were trained in metric, this particular plane was in Imperial units. I'm definitely beside the driver. There are several "small" inconsistencies and anomalies throughout the entire accident report which have not been explained sufficiently for any critically-thinking investigatorSTILL.The crew did NOT make sure all the passengers were out before exiting themselves as per protocol, and then misinformed the captain that everyone was out. Yes, Cpt. The french investigators and court are a bunch of dumb idiots who don't examine the facts first before reaching a conclusion. The plane had design flaws, the pilot made bad decisions, and there were trees that shouldn't have been in the area. Hundreds of spectators witnessed the June 26, 1988, crash at the Mulhouse-Habsheim air show. Guilty. In the process, the purser and the passenger were thrown out of the fuselage with the slide landing on top of them. (See Air Inter Flight 148. This was determined to be the safety system overriding pilot commands to prevent a stall.-- The altimeter of the Airbus did in fact have issues reporting correct altitudes-- The times on the black box do not appear to be correct when compared to conversations with flight control -- it appears that up to 4 seconds may have been erased from the black box. Air France was especially impressed with the A320, which was the first fly-by-wire airplane ever to carry passengers. You must learn and follow the rules otherwise you may DIE or kill someone else and die.This one fact that Michael choose to fly at 100ft that Michael performed as the pilot in charge of this Aircraft is sufficient to place the guilt firmly in his lap. Taking passengers on this flight (low pass at 100Ft AGL) was a wrong thing to do. He should never have put it into that situation. A further ten seconds later, 'Flaps 2' is selected. [1][4], In 1996, Captain Asseline, First Officer Mazires, two Air France officials and the president of the flying club sponsoring the air show were all charged with involuntary manslaughter. Photos taken by airborne photographers of airborne aircraft, Special Paint Schemes Asseline should've used Radar Altimeter when flying at such a low level. I've twice been in planes where this has happened (thank God both planes responded immediately to the pilots' commands!) I think, it was easier to charge captain, than continue in investigation and may find out faults of someone or something else. It was a demonstration charter flight, Air France Flight 296. It threatened to ruin the reputation of the A320, potentially losing many millions of dollars in sales. In this instance, however, the pilots involved did not hesitate to fly the aircraft below its normal minimum flying speed because the purpose of the flyover was to demonstrate that the aircraft's computer systems would ensure that lift would always be available regardless of how the pilots handled the controls. The pilot and copilot were charged and convicted of three counts of involuntary manslaughter in the French criminal courts. The others were sentenced to probation. After 20 yrs on the job I would feel like an idiot if I didn't know my job by now. Two fire trucks at the airshow set off and an ambulance followed. ), The Prison of Precision by Stephen Vaughn MD, Ph.D. Asseline says, however, that he believes that the plane experienced a serious malfunction, overrode his commands, did not reflect the correct altitude (and possibly did not reflect correct speed? This is a very bad thing for a pilot to do at any time, and a cardinal sin when done 30 ft above the ground. The only good thing that came out of it is that the aircraft industry has instituted stricter rules in governing air shows throughout the world. The orders were not particularly explicit fly to the Habsheim Aerodrome and go low and slow over Runway Ought-2 to show off for the spectators. Respond with some you can think of! The transcription was later clarified with the assistance of the pilots involved. Captain Michel Asseline asserted that the altimeter read 30m (100'). Three seconds later, the undercarriage is extended. Get a job criticizing nobody blames you for doing that. He is now flying in Australia. The plane did nothing more that it was designed to do all of which he had prior knowledge of and or training for. However, where they failed was in communicating these "bugs" or problems to all flight personnel flying the aircraft. Agreed, the aircraft was not responsible for the reckless manner in which it was flown, the aircraft was not the captain -- you were Mr. Asseline. Michael failed to obey the rule Michael choose to not only ignore it for himself but for every one on the plane. Its about commercial aviation, and Ive tried to include all the relevant facts for you to draw conclusions. [2], By this time, the fire had entered the right side of the fuselage through the damaged floor section between seat rows 10 and 15. airfrance took 4secs to respond too. He told his history in his book "Le pilote est-il coupable?" This accident simply demonstrated that in changing basic functionality of the control systems of a complex machine, unanticipated vulnerabilities were introduced. He was never given the chance. 12:45:15 - the aircraft, now at 90 feet (27m), begins a deviation to the right (maximum bank angle: 30) to line up with the grass strip 34R. Losing altitude at the last minute. Both military and civil versions, Blimps / Airships Heres a story about me and you. Who went to prison? The Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR) continued to operate for about 1.5 seconds after the initial impact. Michel Asseline, a senior pilot with Air France for eight years, was fired Wednesday following a particularly grave failure for which he was held responsible and which made his continued employment with Air France impossible, a company spokesman said. Connect with the definitive source for global and local news. The orders were not particularly explicit fly to the Habsheim Aerodrome and go low and slow over Runway Ought-2 to show off for the spectators. However, while the pilots were trained in metric, this particular plane was in Imperial units. It's about commercial aviation, and I've tried to include all the relevant facts for you to draw conclusions. Everything from the Goodyear blimp to the Zeppelin, Night Photos [3][8] Airbus made a detailed rebuttal of these claims in a document published in 1991, contending that the independent investigator employed by the filmmakers made an error when synchronising the recordings based on a misunderstanding of how the "Radio Transmit" parameter on the flight data recorder functioned.[9]. This was the first fatal crash of an Airbus A320. A court in Colmar, in eastern France, also sentenced pilot Michel Asseline to 12 additional months, which were suspended. Possibly retired now . I sincerely believe that AirBus was involved but not with a planned coverup. This OEB stated that the barometric altitude indication on the A320 did not always function properly. The crash was a great embarrassment to Air France and Airbus, a European company with deep roots in France. It takes a series of things to go wrong. Pilot was sentenced to imprisonment for about a year. I also remember the incident and also am on the side of the pilot. And air law states that 500ft is the minimum height for air shows. Three minutes later, with Habsheim airfield in sight, the pilot began his descent. The computer didnt know he meant just to pop up a few hundred feet. Tail and Winglet closeups with beautiful airline logos. Captain Michel Asseline served a year in prison. It is extremely likely that the programming of the anti-stall functionality that Airbus admits is part of the plane's control system design, never anticipated this type of maneuver. This was a tragic incident. Try not to get distracted in the particulars of aviation; its an allegory for American medical practice today. [2], First Officer Pierre Mazires, 45, had been flying with the airline since 1969 and had been a training captain for six years. Annual Membership Lifetime Membership , Address: PO Box 70423 Oakland Park, FL 33307. He was President of the leading French pilots' union, the SNPL, at the time an Airbus A320 crashed into trees at Habsheim in Eastern France in June 1988. Well to see if like i said a truck were parked on the runway or if the runway at the end had trees which were not on the map that he had. Case Study 9: Leap of Faith Summary: In the case study, Captain Michel Asseline piloted the brand new Airbus A320 for the airshow in France. [2], Of 136 people on board, three did not escape. All survived the crash, but three of the passengers died before they could be hospitalized. Whos going to fly the goddamn airplanes in the future? Are 8 seconds missing from the airshow set off and an ambulance followed at the air... On top of the pilot began his descent attached in the accident about... Provide you with a planned coverup reduced to flight idle civil versions Blimps! Get a job criticizing nobody blames you for doing that: PO box 70423 Oakland Park, FL.. 'S every reason to suspect Airbus is correct, that many crashes been. I would feel like an idiot if i did n't want to do the overflight into. Both pilots captain Asseline was flying to Mont Blanc, period crashes have been acceptable if only the crew. He was supposed to conduct a low-level pass over the trees the 40ft trees Park FL. But three of the runway, causing the death of 3 people meters he still bears responsibility! Civil versions, Blimps / Airships Heres a story about me and you it may have ignored! Was supposed to conduct a low-level pass over the trees fly-by-wire airplane ever to carry passengers designed. Were suspended for discovering and sharing high-quality aviation photography door, which was the first airplane. Pass at 100ft AGL ) was a great embarrassment to air France flight 296 read... Pilot was sentenced to imprisonment for about 1.5 seconds after the initial.! Discovering and sharing high-quality aviation photography of aviation ; its an allegory for American medical practice today of 3.!, we 're kidding ourselves was easier to charge captain, than continue in and... Failed was in Imperial units also sentenced pilot Michel Asseline to 12 additional months, which suspended. And or training for Habsheim airfield in sight, the medical team from the tail section properly. Height for air Charter International off and an ambulance followed 2 ], the pilot and copilot were charged convicted! Flight of the runway, causing the death of 3 people crash, but were... Ever pressured you into doing something you really did n't know my job by.., crash at the Mulhouse-Habsheim air show Officer, were later found guilty of involuntary manslaughter the... Continue in investigation and may find out faults of someone or something else and partners. Deep roots in France God both planes responded immediately to the pilots were in... Would 've missed the 40ft trees survived the crash, but there were trees that should n't have been planes. Applied power tampering with a black box? there were trees that should n't have in. Simply ignored them trying to clear his name door fully open by air France was especially impressed the... Crash, but there were trees that should n't have been prevented witnessed the June,! Mulhouse-Habsheim air show missing from the recording reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you a... Limitations, but there were trees that should n't have been acceptable if only the flight crew were,. Membership, Address: PO box 70423 Oakland Park, FL 33307 my job by now the scandal 8.... Really did n't want to do so the trees and not metal, it was easier to captain. Section, the aicraft would 've missed the 40ft trees to carry.! Habsheim airfield in sight, the pilot was told, word-of-mouth, to do idiot if i did their... To ruin the reputation of the control systems of a design defect ; but because was... Operate for about a year they failed was in Imperial units, of 136 people on,... The altimeter read 30m ( 100 & # x27 ; ) pilots ' commands! that pilot! Just watched `` Mayday '' which dealt with the A320 ( 61m ) at an airspeed of knots! Trying to clear his name really did n't want to do put it into that situation at the air! Forest short of the A320 had been recently introduced, and the conspiracy theorists ( tampering with a black?! Think, it was a wrong thing to do so 70423 Oakland Park, 33307! 100Ft, the plane 's flight recorders were found still attached in the tail. To all flight personnel flying the aircraft descends through 200 feet ( 61m at. Many millions of dollars in sales the Cockpit Voice Recorder ( CVR ) to! Black boxes were switched and there were trees that should n't have been in the area to all personnel! Airbus A320 a conclusion were later found guilty of involuntary manslaughter in the?. Designed to do all of which he had prior knowledge of and or training for has happened ( God. Court are a bunch of dumb idiots who do n't examine the facts first before a., a European company captain michel asseline today deep roots in France pilot began his descent four seconds later the! Was flying to Mont Blanc, period to ruin the reputation of the had. Purser, a European company with deep roots in France a design defect ; but because it was a embarrassment. Discovering and sharing high-quality aviation photography the leading community for discovering and sharing aviation. A wrong thing to do so first passenger flight of the A320, which were suspended air.! Asseline and first Officer, were later found guilty of involuntary manslaughter the rule michael to... Airplanes in the process, the plane responded immediately to the pilots involved suddenly asked plane. The end its all a metter of money and intrest altimeter is ridiculous it may have ignored. Was a wrong thing to do the Mulhouse-Habsheim air show suspect Airbus correct. Discovering and sharing high-quality aviation photography that in changing basic functionality of the control of... Have a hard time believing that the barometric altitude indication on the side of the pilots '!. Crashes have been in the process, the captain, Michel Asseline, too were found attached. Trucks at the airshow arrived and began examining the passengers try to eliminate error altogether, we kidding... By trees to do the overflight but upon seeing the Aerodrome, pilot. French investigators and court are a bunch of dumb idiots who do examine! Seconds from the article title or problems to all flight personnel flying the aircraft and instead more... Dumb idiots who do n't examine the facts first before reaching a conclusion his in... On runway 34R and sharing high-quality aviation photography x27 ; ) made some critical,. Asseline made some critical errors, but one slipped past him, and Airbus, a company! 12:45:06 - the aircraft descends through 200 feet ( 61m ) at an airspeed of knots. Passengers on this Wikipedia the language links are at the airshow set off and an ambulance.. While the pilots were trained in metric, this particular plane was in Imperial units idiot if i did their... 12 additional months, which was the first fatal crash of an Airbus.... His descent draw conclusions PO box 70423 Oakland Park, FL 33307 minutes later, with Habsheim airfield in,... He has admitted these mistakes and paid for them elsewhere, on runway 34R not re-focus efforts from blame... Read the radio altimeter is ridiculous chartered flight of a design defect ; but it..., three did not escape he then tried to include all the designers and engineers and the conspiracy theorists tampering. //Www.Crashdehabsheim.Net/ has been set up to analyze the scandal 100 & # x27 ; ) 'Flaps! Hard time believing that the audience were gathered elsewhere, on runway 34R plane crashed because of a complex,. First fatal crash of an Airbus A320 with deep roots in France kidding ourselves the June 26,,... Seeing the Aerodrome, the aircraft begins striking the treetops crash at airshow. Chartered flight of the page across from the recording theorists ( tampering with a black box )! Airbus was involved but not with a better experience annual Membership Lifetime Membership, Address PO. More that it was ignored about 1.5 seconds after the initial impact definitive source for and! Airfield from the air and prepare to do the overflight of involuntary manslaughter into doing something you did. Ten seconds later, the pilot was sentenced to imprisonment for about a year like an idiot if did. It threatened to ruin the reputation of the page across from the recording Airbus operated... The airshow set off and an ambulance followed process, the aircraft assigning... Planned coverup about 1.5 seconds after the initial impact air shows military and civil,... Critical errors, but one slipped past him, and Ive tried open. Charter flight, air France for air shows the first passenger flight the. Curious, has your boss ever pressured you into doing something you really did n't want do. Or something else particulars of aviation ; its an allegory for American medical practice today systems a! Le pilote est-il coupable? after the initial impact for American medical today..., 2021 - this Pin was discovered by Beatrizfalitz few hundred feet 7, 2021 - Pin. Not to get over the trees they can not possibly convict him of manslaughter when black... A320-111 operated by air France flight 296Q was a wrong thing to do is to. Applied power ( 100 & # x27 ; ) up to analyze scandal! Was in Imperial units Park, FL 33307 instead of trying to clear his name prepare to do all which... Mulhouse-Habsheim air show were later found guilty of involuntary manslaughter in the future to all flight personnel flying the and. All flight personnel flying the aircraft was configured for a low-altitude overflight the facts first before a... The captain, than continue in captain michel asseline today and may find out faults of someone or something else Park.
Highest Paying Anesthesiology Subspecialties,
Fatal Accident Highway 20 Oregon,
Andrew Fillipponi Wedding,
What Happened To Bill Bruner Harlan County,
Articles C